Short answer
Choose xTool P2S or OMTech Polar when clear acrylic is central to the work: both use a CO₂ source. xTool S1 is relevant for dark or opaque acrylic and mixed diode work, but it is not a substitute for CO₂ on clear acrylic.
Choose for your actual job
Research-based shortlist, not a hands-on ranking. These scenarios explain which documented differences matter; they do not establish measured performance.
Clear acrylic with a guided CO₂ workflow
P2S
Its CO₂ source is relevant to clear acrylic; compare the documented bed and positioning workflow.
Look elsewhere if: The complete extraction, cooling and installation budget exceeds your limit.
An alternative enclosed CO₂ setup
Polar 50W
Compare its work area and complete installation with P2S using the same sheet and fixture.
Look elsewhere if: Your required sheet or fixture does not fit the documented usable area.
Dark acrylic and mixed diode engraving
S1 40W
Consider this diode workflow only for compatible dark or opaque acrylic and other documented materials.
Look elsewhere if: Clear acrylic cutting is central to your orders.
Compare the documented workflow
Work areas and capture figures are manufacturer specifications, not our measurements. Compare fixture clearance or a representative scan before buying; software listed here does not imply that every licence is included.
| Machine | Key specification | Software | Main limitation | Record checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| xTool P2S | 600 mm × 308 mm | xTool Creative Space, LightBurn | Requires extraction, cooling and more floor space | 2026-10-05 |
| OMTech Polar 50W | 510 mm × 300 mm | LightBurn | Exhaust routing and maintenance need dedicated space | 2026-10-05 |
| xTool S1 40W | 498 mm × 319 mm | xTool Creative Space, LightBurn | Opaque enclosure means no live camera preview | 2026-10-05 |
Source type decides clear-acrylic support
CO₂ wavelengths are absorbed by clear acrylic, while common blue-diode machines generally need dark, opaque or specially formulated acrylic. Do not infer compatibility from the word acrylic alone.
Compare the installed workflow
Extraction, cooling, bed type, camera alignment and fire-safe placement matter as much as nominal laser output. Include filters, ducting and material testing in the setup budget.
- Confirm the largest sheet and usable work area.
- Check edge-finish requirements before promising finished products.
- Never process PVC or unidentified plastics.
Where the shortlist stops
We checked source type, work area, enclosure, positioning workflow and independent assessments. Throughput still needs testing with your exact thickness and material supplier.



