Comparison · direct decision support
xTool P2S vs xTool S1 40W
CO₂ versatility and clear-acrylic cutting versus a lower-cost enclosed diode workflow.
- Official sources
- Limitations included
- Checked 2026-10-05
Quick decision
Where each machine fits
xTool
Choose P2S if…
- Cuts clear acrylic and thicker organic materials
- Dual cameras support layout and close-up positioning
Watch for
- Requires extraction, cooling and more floor space
- Higher setup cost than enclosed diode systems
xTool
Choose S1 40W if…
- Class 1 enclosed design
- Interchangeable laser modules and accessory ecosystem
Watch for
- Opaque enclosure means no live camera preview
- Ventilation remains necessary for smoke and fumes
Side by side
Verified differences
Swipe horizontally to compare both machines →
| Decision point | P2S | S1 40W |
|---|---|---|
| Reference price | $4,999 | $2,199 |
| Laser type | co2 laser | diode laser |
| Laser output | 55 W | 40 W |
| Work area | 600 mm × 308 mm | 498 mm × 319 mm |
| Fully enclosed | Yes | Yes |
| Camera | Yes | No |
| Autofocus | Yes | Yes |
| Rotary support | Yes | Yes |
| Materials | clear acrylic, wood, leather, rubber, coated metal | wood, leather, dark acrylic, coated metal |
| Best suited to | acrylic, wood, leather, home business | wood, leather, acrylic, home business |
| Strongest case | Cuts clear acrylic and thicker organic materials | Class 1 enclosed design |
| Main limitation | Requires extraction, cooling and more floor space | Opaque enclosure means no live camera preview |
| Record checked | 2026-10-05 | 2026-10-05 |
Reference prices exclude some accessories, extraction and market-specific costs. Published accuracy and resolution are manufacturer figures, not our test results.
Evidence log
Sources used
- xTool P2S: xTool P2S product pageofficial · checked 2026-10-05
- xTool S1 40W: xTool S1 product pageofficial · checked 2026-10-05
Continue comparing
Related comparisons
- Related comparison
xTool P2S vs OMTech Polar
A direct comparison of two enclosed desktop CO₂ lasers for commercial cutting.
- Related comparison
xTool S1 vs Creality Falcon2 Pro 40W
Enclosed 40 W diode lasers compared for workflow, work area and safety features.
- Related comparison
xTool S1 40W vs WeCreat Vision 20W
Higher cutting power and a larger ecosystem compared with camera-guided personalization at a lower reference price.